Hot cross buns are a given at Easter…and they’re lovely! There are such a huge range of flavours available these days, but sometimes it’s nice to think a little outside of the box (within the Easter realms). If you’re hosting, or simply want something a little more memorable, it’s nice to have a few Easter baking ideas that feel unmistakably seasonal without being overly themed.
Chocolate…marzipan…a little nostalgia (and a little tradition).
These three recipes strike that balance. They work beautifully on a relaxed spring table, like the one I shared in my Easter table setting ideas, and pair naturally with my alternative Easter lunch ideas if you’re planning the full day.
We’ll make:
- Mini Egg brownie squares
- No bake Creme Egg cheesecake
- A lighter simnel cake with toasted marzipan
All clearly Easter, just done with a bit of restraint!
Choosing the Right Dessert from These Easter Baking Ideas
Let’s be honest, as much as I could eat all three, you don’t really need them. So which one should you go for?
If you’re hosting a larger lunch, the Creme Egg cheesecake makes a generous centrepiece.
Keeping things smaller? The brownies slice easily and work well with coffee.
Or, if you enjoy something slightly more traditional, the simnel cake brings that unmistakable Easter flavour without feeling heavy or dated.
Think about:
- How many people you’re serving
- How much oven space you have
- Whether you want something you can make ahead
Easter baking should add to the day, not complicate it.

1. Mini Egg Brownie Squares
Chocolatey, slightly fudgy and topped with crushed Mini Eggs (who doesn’t love Mini Eggs…) for colour and crunch.
They’re familiar for a reason, and they work!
Ingredients
200g dark chocolate
180g unsalted butter
250g caster sugar
3 large eggs
100g plain flour
30g cocoa powder
150g Mini Eggs, roughly crushed
Equipment
- Medium saucepan
- Heatproof bowl
- Whisk
- 20cm square baking tin – a sturdy square brownie tin helps you get clean, even slices
- Baking parchment
- Spatula – a silicone spatula makes folding the mixture easier without overmixing
- Cooling rack
Method
- Preheat oven to 180°C fan.
- Melt chocolate and butter together in a bowl over a saucepan of simmering water until smooth.
- Remove from heat and whisk in sugar.
- Add eggs one at a time, whisking until glossy (make sure the mixture has cooled sufficiently before you do this!)
- Fold in flour and cocoa gently.
- Pour into lined tin and scatter crushed Mini Eggs over the top.
- Bake 25–30 minutes until set at the edges but slightly soft in the centre.
- Cool fully before slicing.
Serve on a large wooden serving board for a relaxed feel – this works really well for casual Easter desserts.
2. No Bake Creme Egg Cheesecake (my favourite of these Easter baking ideas!)
The minute Creme Eggs arrive in the shop, you know that Easter is on its way! (for me, that’s usually the minute Christmas is over)
This dessert is unmistakably Easter. Rich chocolate base, creamy filling, and halved Creme Eggs pressed gently into the top.
Indulgent, yes. But styled simply, it feels grown up rather than novelty.
Ingredients
For the base:
200g digestive biscuits
100g unsalted butter, melted
For the filling:
300g full fat cream cheese
100g icing sugar
1 tsp vanilla extract
300ml double cream
6 Creme Eggs, chopped
To decorate:
3 to 4 Creme Eggs, halved
Equipment
- Food processor ( you can’t go wrong with this compact Kenwood!) or rolling pin
- Mixing bowls
- Electric hand mixer – this saves time and gives a smoother filling
- 20cm springform tin – a reliable cake tin makes removal clean and effortless
- Spatula
Method
- Crush biscuits into fine crumbs and mix with melted butter.
- Press firmly into lined tin and chill 30 minutes.
- Beat cream cheese, icing sugar and vanilla until smooth.
- Whip cream separately until soft peaks form.
- Fold cream into cream cheese mixture.
- Stir through chopped Creme Eggs.
- Spoon onto chilled base and smooth.
- Chill at least 4 hours or overnight.
- Decorate with halved Creme Eggs before serving.
Serve on a simple glass cake stand to let the colours stand out – this clear glass cake stand elevates even a no bake dessert.

3. Lighter Simnel Cake with Toasted Marzipan
Simnel cake is traditional Easter baking, and comes steeped in tradition. But, it doesn’t need to be dense or overly decorated.
This version keeps the almond flavour and marzipan layer, but feels lighter.
Ingredients
200g unsalted butter
180g light brown sugar
3 large eggs
200g self raising flour
100g ground almonds
1 tsp baking powder
1 tsp mixed spice
150g mixed dried fruit
Zest of 1 orange
200g marzipan
Equipment
- 20cm round cake tin
- Electric mixer
- Spatula
- Rolling pin
- Pastry brush – this makes glazing the top much neater
Method
- Preheat oven to 170°C fan.
- Cream butter and sugar until pale.
- Beat in eggs gradually.
- Fold in flour, ground almonds, baking powder and spice.
- Stir in fruit and orange zest.
- Spoon half into lined tin.
- Roll out half marzipan and lay over batter.
- Add remaining mixture and smooth.
- Bake 60–75 minutes until golden.
- Cool, brush with apricot jam and top with thin marzipan circle.
- Lightly toast under grill until just golden.
If you’re a minimalist, keep decoration low key. But if you love marzipan and want to pay respect to tradition, then go all out with a few marzipan balls!

Make Ahead and Storage for These Easter Baking Ideas
All three of these Easter baking ideas can be prepared in advance:
- Brownies – These keep well for two days in an airtight container.
- Cheesecake –The cheesecake benefits from being made the day before and kept chilled.
- Simnel cake – This keeps for several days wrapped tightly, making it ideal if you want to bake earlier in the week.
Planning ahead leaves you free to focus on your table and guests.
Easter Baking Ideas: Frequently Asked Questions
What are traditional Easter baking ideas?
Traditional Easter baking includes simnel cake, hot cross buns and marzipan topped fruit cakes. Modern variations often include chocolate egg based desserts.
Can I make Easter desserts ahead of time?
Yes. Cheesecakes and brownies are ideal for preparing the day before. Simnel cake can be baked several days in advance.
What makes a bake feel Easter themed?
Chocolate eggs, marzipan, spring flavours and subtle pastel decoration all signal Easter without needing heavy themed decorations.
Easter Baking Ideas That Feels Seasonal, Not Overdone
The best Easter baking ideas feel recognisable but not exaggerated:
- A little chocolate nostalgia.
- A nod to tradition.
- A fresh spring table to sit around.
You don’t need everything piled high with decorations. Just choose one recipe, bake it properly, and serve it simply!
If you’re planning the wider celebration, you’ll find everything gathered in my Easter guide.
And for more relaxed seasonal hosting inspiration throughout the year, explore the Food & Entertaining collection where gatherings are designed to feel manageable rather than overwhelming.






